I was just 14 years old. It was August 1969, and I was working at one of my very first jobs, as a busboy at Norm’s Restaurant during the ten-day run of the New York State Fair. Norm’s was not one of those tiny booths that popped up like mushrooms during Fair week and then disappeared for a full year, but a sprawling, cafeteria-style restaurant on the far south end of the aging Horticultural Building.
Anyway, we staffers (most of us, wet-behind-the-ears school kids) were told by Ada Rothschild, Norm’s wife (who pretty much ran the joint), that at 10 AM we we'd be serving 50 Gold Star mothers. I had no idea what a Gold Star mother was, so I just went with it.
And, sure enough, at 10 o’clock those 50 mothers came parading in to eat whatever it was we'd agreed to serve them. To my 14-year old eyes, the ladies were ancient; every one well over 50, maybe even 60 or 70, all with gray hair and, more often than not, thick, cat's eye or gold-rimmed glasses. They were also all dressed in something that appeared to be a nurse’s uniform, with every last one sporting a little white hat featuring, as their name suggested, a tiny gold star.
As I was going about my business, cleaning dishes, piling up trays and wiping tables, I noticed one of the mothers watching me closely. Every time I looked over I caught her stealing glances my way. And unlike the others, she was not seated in a group. Instead, she sat all alone, her small plate of food in front of her. And she didn't wear glasses, but had the icy blue eyes of a much younger woman.
Eventually, as I was walking by she smiled and said a soft, “Hello.” I did the same. Then shortly thereafter, as I was wiping down a table adjacent to her, she asked me if I’d like to join her. I told her I really couldn’t. I said I had a job to do. But even as I was saying that, I found myself pulling out the chair across from her and sitting down.
It was though her eyes and their inherent warmth and tenderness had beckoned me, and I was almost powerless to do a thing about it. And those eyes, even at probably 70 years old, were mesmerizing. They were both beautiful and full of sparkle, and they communicated a depth of character that was so palpable that, I swear, I felt I could almost touch it.
As she stared at me, smiling, in a very soft and tender voice she started asking me about myself. What was my name? Where did I go to school? What grade was I in? What did I like to do with my spare time? Did I have lots of friends? Did I like baseball? And the whole time this was going on, I kept looking directly into those blue eyes of hers, which continued to look back at me with a love that even my own mother would probably have a hard time topping.
Finally, I apologized and said I had to get back to work. I said it was nice talking to her and I hoped she'd have fun at the Fair, but I really had a job to do. Her eyes glistened a goodbye, and she smiled at me one last time. And that was the last I ever thought of her.
Until the following year.
I was back working at Norm’s for Fair Week. The Gold Star mothers were again headed our way at 10 AM. And once again we were told to be on our toes. But this time I asked Ada something I should have thought to ask her twelve months prior. “What the heck,” I asked, "is a Gold Star mother?”
Ada looked at me as if I had carrots growing out my ears, and said, “You’ve never heard of the Gold Star mothers? Those are mothers who've had a son killed in war.”
I stood there dumbstruck, the realization hitting me like a 2x4 to my thick skull. The woman wasn’t staring at me because I was a nice guy, or especially cute, or happened to clean tables particularly well. She was staring at me because something about me apparently reminded her of her son who'd been killed while defending his country -- my country.
I was stunned. I couldn't talk. And for a moment I could barely move or breathe. All I knew that was when I eventually turned away from Ada, who'd returned to doing whatever it was she'd been doing, my eyes were brimming with tears.
Because even though I'd never answered my doorbell during wartime, never been handed a little brownish yellow telegram from the War Department, and never been forced to slowly read the thing, including the chilling words “ We regret to inform you…”, I’d come as close as I would ever want to.
I had stared deep into the eyes of a World War II mother who’d actually gotten such a telegram, and who'd actually read it. And I, for the briefest of moments beheld, in all its power and majesty, the very thing that almost killed that woman and yet somehow allowed her to soldier on.
I saw and felt the enormity of her love. It was just a tiny sliver of it, I'll admit that, but that was more than enough. Because I saw in her a love she'd always carry in her heart, a love that allowed her to get up each morning and face the day, even after learning that the son she'd once cradled in her arms and sung to sleep at night had given his life so that his fellow Upstate New Yorkers -- including knuckleheads like me and my friends -- could continue to go to state fairs, play baseball, shoot off fireworks, and, yes, bus tables.
It’s late on Memorial Day, 2015. I was getting ready for bed a moment ago. But as I was brushing my teeth and putting a fresh set of sheets on the bed, she came to me again, just as she’s done every Memorial Day for the past 45 years. My Gold Star memory. As I was putting on the fitted sheet, there she was; that beautiful, loving, selfless woman seated at one of Norm's tables, smiling at me yet again, and looking into my eyes for a trace of her son.
And I had to sit down right there on the bed as she visited me yet again. And for a few moments I remembered one more time that morning so many years ago when I got to sit at arm’s length and look into the soul of a courageous mother, gentle warrior, and true American hero, a remarkable woman who, as Abraham Lincoln might have written, had laid so costly a sacrifice on the altar of freedom.
That’s why I’m writing this now, while my bed sits unmade. I figured it was time to finally commit my Gold Star memory to words ,and to honor a woman and her heroic son, a guy I only got to know as a reflection in his mother's eye, but a guy with whom I'm sure I would have loved to have had a chance to go a ballgame, share a joke, or knock back a cold one or two.
Here’s to our freedoms, my friends. Here’s to our Gold Star mothers. And here’s to all those from coast to coast who have paid so dearly on a debt we all owe.
May you and yours have a joyous, peaceful, and meaningful Memorial Day.

Beautiful recollection.
Thanks so much. Like so many stories the best thing it seems the writer can do is just tell it and not get in the way. Let the story, in other words, speak for itself. That's, hopefully, what I was able to do here.
It's a debt we owe that can never be repaid. Thanks for the story MC.
Thanks, T. Different world than the one were brought up in, huh?
My dad never wanted to talk about his military time. I only knew that he hated to emmerse himself in water. He showered every day, but wouldn't take a bath because he had been shot down and ditched in the Atlantic 5 times, One day while we were sitting in the car shortly after I'd enlisted in the Air Force my father told me his story. My father was stationed with his group someplace in Italy and some of his friends from the famous "Boys from Syracuse" were partying in Rome and asked my dad to join them, which he did. All his buddies were ribbing him "John, you really blew it this time!.This is a 'milk run' (a mission with a minimum amount of danger). Only xx more missions and you'll complete your 50 and can go back home!" The entire squadron was lost. They were all awarded the silver star including my dad because he was a member of the squadron. But my dad thought it was ridiculous for him to get a silver star while he was in Rome partying and all his buddies were dieing.
MC,
Great recollection of a beautiful story. I can relate. My son is a USMA grad and his best friend at West Point (and roommate at school and during their first posting) was killed in Afghanistan in 2005. My wife and I knew his family well and to this day we attend the annual 5K in MA that is a fund raiser for the foundation his family started to assist NE veterans and their families in need. Every year, we see the incredible sadness that his family, especially his mother, have had to bear for over 20 years. God bless all of the veterans who made the ultimate sacrifice and their families who had to endure this unimaginable grief. As a side note, Arnie Rothschild, Norm's son, hired me for my first "big" job in broadcasting at WSYR Radio. Thanks, Huck
Thank you so much, Huck. Two things: I am so sorry about your son's friend. I hope his family is doing their best to live with the pain and their son's memory. I truly can't imagine what that must be like. Also, not sure if you know this, but Arnie is still alive and shaking things up over in Rochester, where he's lived for years. Happy Memorial Day to you and the family, and thanks again.
Another masterpiece
M.C..you always emotionally move me. I do think with a bit of touch up, the Gold Star Mother that keeps on appearing before you could be an excellent, Twilight Zone episode.
I was in same classification as you, Young Americans that didnt know what had happened 25 years prior..
But David Bowie wrote a song about Young Americans.
https://youtu.be/ydLcs4VrjZQ?si=Dltq-2Gu-HJ09wyR
Thank you.
What a great take M. Love your story telling. Brings a tear of joy to my eye.
Again, MC, thanks so much for your poignant commentary!
MC thanks for reposting. I missed it 1st time around. My mother was a Gold Star. We lost my brother Marty in Vietnam in 1970. You never forget the notification. She was fortunate to have 7 other sons to help get thru the heartbreak. Touches home. Thanks
I never knew that about Marty, Roger. I'm so sorry. That must have brought Vietnam home in a way that few of us ever had to deal with. Someday, I'd like to hear all about Marty. Those guys who fought in Vietnam were just kids, like the rest of us, but kids who were given an absolutely thankless task. Worse, we treated them like sh*t when those who came home, actually did. Thanks for reaching out. Once again, I'm so sorry. And I hope to see you soon.